Perhaps I’m biased, and there anglers in other regions of the Appalachians, and the northeastern US, that would object to me stating that the term Brookie Crick originated in Pennsylvania. But nonetheless, regardless of the location of the origin of the term, there is probably further dissention still about what defines a Brookie Crick. To me, a Brookie Crick, mostly should be defined by those streams that possess turtle sized rocks, covered in the most verdant moss imaginable, and outstanding riparian vegetation. Whether it is pine and hemlocks, maples, beeches and oaks, or perhaps a combination of all, and others as well, the trees shade the water and keep the stream banks intact. The gradient of these streams is usually substantial and creates miniature pools and chutes of fast water in some areas, and generally if you can see far enough in front of you, and go far enough to the source, at some point of time, you’ll see a staircase of pools and riffles in such streams. The simplification of the water character of these types of streams would be “bubbly”. The combination of rocks, trees, plants, and essentially drift wood, in these streams would make the most creative water landscape artist green with envy, and no man could even hope to ever re-create. Simply put, these streams that lace the mountains from Georgia to Maine all along the spine of the Appalachians are among the most beautiful places in the world.
And perhaps it rings so true that in these pristine watersheds, the water they give forth is the gift of life itself, and a by product of the health of the watershed. And in these, pristine, cold waters, populations of wild trout thrive and flourish. Some may argue that brown trout should go and do not belong in these streams, and generally I agree with that. We absolutely should preserve populations of Brook Trout. But, it’s not like these two trout species are rivals in the sense that in these small brooks, Browns will win out and Brookies would be no more. I have not seen any evidence of that. In fact, go far enough to the source of the stream, and Brookies always prevail. You’ll find these tiny trout in streams that you can leap across, and they seem to be doing fine in areas that are not degraded, and have clean cold water. And yes, Browns eat Brookies, but Brookies also eat other Brookies too. So these two species survive generally well together where the water is cold enough to support Brookies in addition to the Browns. And then it is fitting that where there are native, wild, Brookies, you then and only then have a Brookie Crick.
There are minor differences between a Brookie Crick in say, North Carolina, and one in Pennsylvania, and one in New Hampshire. But suffice to say, you’ll know one when you see one. This scene pretty much says it all……And you could find similar scenes anywhere in the Appalachians and the northeast, though this one is in Pennsylvania.
The scene is a display of the lushness of late spring/early summer, climatologically speaking. This is the time of the year that spring’s ample precipitation and cooler temps are giving way to drier, warmer weather. In terms of the life of a trout, and the people who fly fish for them, its Green Drake time. This is the grand finale of spring’s insect feast. Jumbo sized mayflies that hatch during this season, and provide abundant protein for the denizens of the stream. From this point on through the summer, except in wet, cool years, life gets tough for the trout. The water continues to be reduced in volume, and also warms, at times too warm to keep the fish active and healthy. They are anxiously awaiting September’s cool nights and fall’s more frequent rains, which allow the fish to once again spread out and colonize areas of the stream that were off limits for the summer. Overall, these fish live in a most dynamic environment, and are as tough, tenacious, and durable as life itself.
Perhaps that is a trait of these places that makes me wants to be there and fish for these survivors. Or more superficially, maybe it’s just because these are places of outstanding beauty. Or perhaps I just like being able to catch these jewel-like wild trout, that make up for their shortcomings in size, with vigor and reckless abandon. What ever the reason, and for certain there are more, not only my reasons either, but for other anglers that are limited only by their imaginations; they have their reasons too.
And fish these streams I do, whenever I get a chance to do so. Recently, I was fishing a very famous stream, where the water was too warm, and the fish had too much to eat, and the sun was too bright, and the water was low, and a thousand other reason why I was not able to catch more, or any fish that day. And so, there was only one fishing tactic left to resort to – I had to fish a Brookie Crick. These streams are the perfect elixir when the more famous, filthy rich with food streams, that kick your angling confidence down a few clicks. These are not the streams to contemplate whether the fish will take a dun, an emerger, or a spinner. These streams are the elk hair caddis, or parachute Adams type of fly selection streams. Nothing fancy, or cute, just a basic, buggy looking fly that sometimes represents a half a dozen different types of insects will usually suffice to get a fish to rise and take the imitation. Here’s one such place that the fish like an elk hair caddis pitched into the foam lines. There’s a bunch of lemon and lime Sallies, or in lay terms, small stoneflies that inhabit this stream, and the trout are acutely aware of them.

This is one of those quintessential, prototypical Brookie Cricks, that when you’re on it and catching fish, you find it hard to stop fishing. As you always have to see what’s up around the next bend or see what the next larger size pool looks like, where the biggest trout in the stream may have taken up residence. The allure of these streams is endless and at times they are as addicting as heroin when the fish are compliant, the weather is pleasant, and you are in the process of shaking off the doldrums of winter. They are nothing short of a celebration of spring time angling and the warm weather to come.
Sometimes these streams are actually quite large for what one usually considers a Brookie Crick. Here’s one of these larger waters.

Yep, I know what you’re thinking; this is a big fish pool. I would also have to agree. However, I do not have any tangible evidence to support that theory. This pool only yielded a 6” Brookie that fell to my offering, and nothing more. Perhaps the larger fish in this pool are strictly carnivorous, and do not rise for a #14 dry fly. For some reason, even the prospect of catching one of these kings of the stream, is something that I am not going to pursue with great vigor. The thought of pitching a streamer (even though I did fish a streamer in this pool) to all the likely looking lunker habitat, and constantly changing from dries to streamers and back again, is something that carries little appeal to me. I like the dry fly for these waters. The water below is a fine, moderate flow dry fly stretch of a Brookie Crick.
Note the perfect stream banks with vegetation right down the stream. This stream does not dirty from normal, and even slightly above normal precipitation. And if it does cloud, it clears as soon as the deluge stops. And because of that, it hosts all sediment sensitive aquatic life. Probably much as it was 400 years ago. On the day that this picture was taken and we fished this stream, we found a fawn, no more than a day or two old, hunkered down and it did not bolt from us. Of course, we left the fawn as we found it after taking a couple of pictures. Mom was probably within sight distance, though we never saw her.
On more than one occasion over the years, I almost had perfectly good underwear ruined from fawns exploding from the vegetation right under my feet. It’s an event that you don’t soon forget, but it always takes you by surprise when it occurs.
Speaking of surprises, here’s the best Brookie of a recent excursion to the head waters of a famous tributary of a famous trout stream. Best I can tell, he’s back in the same spot, waiting for an elk hair caddis……

Parting Shot
The picture below is what a watershed that hosts many such streams looks like in the Northeast. Note the miles of unbroken forest canopy. Also worth noting is that this land was timbered off around the early 1900’s. And while to the casual observer this looks like the restoration is complete, that is not true. The original forest, was predominately pines and hemlocks. The distinction is that the old growth forest of pines and hemlocks was like a giant sponge, and absorbed immense amounts of precipitation, and then slowly released the cold water into the seepages and trickles. The pine and hemlock forests also shaded the under story and forest floor, so that evaporation was very slow. As opposed to the mostly deciduous forests of today, in which evaporation is high when the trees do not have leaves. And when the trees have leaves, deciduous trees tend to be quite thirsty as well. The flows of years gone by were more consistent and less subject to spate conditions, than today. This in turn was good for the native Brook Trout. But the forests are still evolving and if left to keep evolving, will gradually become the thick, dark forests of years ago. This is a critical characteristic for long term health of Brookie Cricks.

Oh, one more thing, us anglers that fish these gems, are very protective about them, and are almost paranoid about other anglers fishing in their secret beat. Myself, I might tell someone in person about where I fished last, but the vast abyss of cyberspace is not the place to divulge such information. They exist; go find ‘em.